r/rit • u/study-in-alteRITy Alum • Mar 23 '21
[#CampusLife] Intro
A common joke when I went to RIT, over a decade ago, was “how do you know you’re a woman at RIT? It’s week one and you already have a stalker.”
The culture I experienced in engineering had this engrained; stalking culture was the norm, unwanted attention and harassment was the norm, and the worst aspects of “nerd culture”, such as casual misogyny and a high acceptance of creepy behavior, flourished without question.
I keep seeing words to describe the culture for women in STEM like "chilly" or "hostile", but I see very few stories to explain why it feels like that, especially for womens' college experiences. That's where we lose the bulk of women from the leaky STEM pipeline.
So I’d like to post a couple times a week about something from my experience at RIT.
Here’s my first stalking story:
I had a class that was at night, so the lab was also late.
One time I left lab and was walking back to the dorms. There were still a few people around campus, but I started to get the feeling that someone was following me. But it’s kinda hard to tell, you know? Plenty of people walk the quarter mile without intentionally following someone, so maybe I was just being paranoid.
But just around the SAU the rest of the crowd had died out and I heard someone increasing their pace, and some gut alarm went off. I started digging through my purse for my pepper spray, but I was too late. The guy came up on me, I screamed, and he jumped, tackling me to the ground with his arms fully around me.
This was the first time at RIT that I really thought I was going to die. There’s a physical reaction that happens with that. Stomach sinking, heart racing, and time feels like it has slowed down.
He got off me and I scrambled back to my feet. He was really angry at me for screaming. He said it made him seem like some kind of bad guy, and he wasn’t, he was my friend.
I told him that I didn’t know who he was, and he told me that wasn’t so. He reminded me that we’d met at a student mixer. That was true. Once he said it, I remembered, we had met and talked for maybe ten minutes several weeks prior. He’d seemed like a perfectly normal person the first time I met him. Even cute.
I told him that he’d just followed me, for a significant distance, I suspected, and then tackled me. He told me that it was a “jump hug” and that we were friends so it was fine and normal to greet me with a “jump hug”. He also complained about having to wait two hours for my lab to get out and having to follow me for such a distance to get me on my own. And about how I screamed. Instead of appreciating his friendship, I assume.
I found the first group I could— a bunch of fraternity guys over by that rock doing something with the paint— and asking them to walk me home.
And here’s the thing that makes this story different from most of the rest of my stories: the fraternity boys were super supportive. I told them what happened, they found it horrifying, and they promised they’d get me home safe.
I also told my lab partner about it, and he was angry it had happened, and he volunteered to walk me home from then on out, so that’s what we did. It was really helpful and I felt much safer than I would’ve on my own.
No one blamed me for being out after dark or walking on my own or asked what I was wearing or anything. A+ for support for everyone involved here. Except for the stalker guy.
49
u/SANSationalPunMaster Mar 23 '21
I’ve had men openly admit to stalking women to their faces.
43
u/study-in-alteRITy Alum Mar 23 '21
Yeah. I'm not surprised to hear that. A lot of guys bragged to me about how long they'd waited for me, and how far they'd stalked me.
I think it speaks to how accepted it was. No one thought what they were doing was wrong or bad or something they should not be doing.
12
u/SANSationalPunMaster Mar 23 '21
It’s sad this is still happening today and social media certainly does not make it easier. Not just for stalking but for how many men can now join together on servers and defend each other’s behavior
67
u/NitrousR6 cjo | MET | 2024 Mar 23 '21
Yeah as a guy, I tend to keep a very far distance from any woman on campus just because I don't want to worry them, sometimes I even purposefully slow down when in a hurry when I see a girl in front of me, and take my time, because being on time is not worth another's discomfort.
I dread these stories because I know it happens a lot and I hate that it happens so often because of the "nerd culture" at RIT and guys that are way too horny to be on campus.
I heard a similar story from a girl in my FYW class freshman year that she gets followed all the time after one of her later classes and she had a talk with the professor about it and seeking help. Its so fucked when you hear that in FRESHMAN YEAR, like, jesus christ, just getting to college and you're already having a traumatizing experience.
Fuck stalkers.
27
u/study-in-alteRITy Alum Mar 23 '21
Thanks for being aware of your actions, and it's great to hear your anti-stalking attitude. It also feels good to have stalking acknowledged as traumatic. It is.
5
u/peterkos CS'22, MUSIC'?? Mar 25 '21
Likewise. I also try to make some sort of noise like, shuffling my feet as I walk so I don't just pop up behind someone.
3
u/meg_is_asleep Apr 04 '21
Yeah, it was really weird for me getting to RIT because I had been sexually harassed before, but never in a way that felt like I was being viewed as a potential target. Then, in my first week of freshman year, I managed to have an unsettling encounter with a man who I had talked with at an orientation event and then walked around campus with. He told me he didn’t have social media, so we exchanged phone numbers, and then after that he would keep texting and texting and tried to use the excuse “I told you I was clingy”. I had never had any real experience with this sort of behavior, and I’m quite lucky my roommate and I instantly became fast friends, because they were probably the reason I actually made the decision to tell him to stop texting me or else I would not pursue a friendship. He did not stop texting me, and I avoided him in our shared class for the rest of the semester. I haven’t spoken to him since, but when I got Snapchat at the beginning of quarantine in order to communicate with some of the other people in my major, he added me as a friend, which I found unnerving. I’m aware that his behavior could simply be indicative of poor social skills and a lack of self-awareness, but it could also be something darker, and I don’t feel safe taking that chance. I am not a small girl, but he is still taller, and I think he lives in the same apartment complex as I do this year. If it turns out that he was just awkward, I really hope he has made friends who are there for him
23
u/Farandolai Alum Mar 23 '21
Freshman 2011 required student orientation got me a stalker week 1, he wasn't too bad at first and I chalked up all the seemingly random times he found me on the quarter mile to having a class end at the same time. The worst incident was he saw me in the corner store and put down his basket full of stuff to follow be back to my dorm building and try to push in past the swipe required doors. I was lucky he dropped it after a month or so and it didn't escalate since I was terrified of confrontation.
12
u/study-in-alteRITy Alum Mar 24 '21
I'm really sorry. It's the worst when they try to follow you back to your place.
A month is a long time to deal with that.
16
Mar 24 '21
I hate that as women we've been taught to dismiss our gut feelings about things like being followed as being paranoid or even being conceited or something. I feel like what our "gut" is picking up on is someone matching our pace so even when we speed up or slow down the individual always seems to be right in front of us or right behind us because it's really unlikely someone will remain pace matching you for a long stretch unless it's on purpose (either because you're walking together or they're following you). Luckily I was never jumped at RIT, that must have been terrifying and it's so gross that he tried to shift the blame of his gross and entitled behavior onto you. And hugs require consent too, you don't just get to go around hugging or touching whoever you want without their permission. I'm so mad on your behalf.
I remember my freshman year there was a guy in some of my classes that would go "I saved you a seat Hi_Jynx!" with his backpack, and I shit you not, would say "and they say chivalry is dead!" Every. Single. Time. It was a little awkward but I didn't think much of it at first. Of course, I'm not someone who is good at waking up on time and I would often take the ill advised between classes naps and come to class a few minutes late so I would just slip in and sit in the closest available seat to the door as to not draw even more attention to myself. I think for the two hour classes there was a break sometimes and he would, in the break, come to me and in a very guilt-trippy way go "why didn't you sit next to me? I saved you a seat!" Later that quarter (yee olde quarter system) I started dating someone else that was in the same physics class/group as this guy and me and the guy started acting weird and a little bit hostile towards the group. At one point he was hogging the group's problem set to himself and I was so annoyed I took it from him and put it somewhere everyone could look at and work on it without needing to lean over the table or cram into each others' personal space and he got upset and walked out. After that I went out of my way to avoid him and he would sort of follow me around campus so I was more or less always looking over my shoulder or walking fast to get away from him. It went on that way for a while and he even asked my boyfriend, while he was stuck selling baked goods for his fraternity's bake sale, why I was mad at him. The next year we were both placed in Riverknoll and somehow were only in the shared laundry building once the entire time, but that one time he was still trying to talk to me and I just ignored him and acted like I couldn't hear or see him because I really don't know what else to do in that situation and luckily that was the last time he tried to harass me. But the part about that story that makes me really angry is remembering how when I was telling a friend of mine that I thought this guy was creepy his response was "you think everyone is creepy" which is not true and so dismissive.
9
u/study-in-alteRITy Alum Mar 24 '21
Yeah, I think you're right about our "gut"-- both what it's doing and how we're taught to dismiss it.
Ugh, I'm so sorry about your creep experience. The guys who are pretending to be nice are the worst, because it's genuinely hard to tell them to just piss off (and oh man, everyone else gets mad if you do, because you were mean to the poor creep). And that place where they've crossed the line from plausibly nice to obviously bad just seems to sneak right past you in the moment. And yeah, like you, I found a lot of my friends were very dismissive of my problems creepy behavior, which just made everything so much harder.
13
u/raven_785 Mar 24 '21
Some things never change, sadly. In my time at RIT in the early to mid aughts there was a prolific creeper completely out in the open about it who was well known to much of campus. One incoming freshman had filed a restraining order against him before even arriving on campus for orientation due to harassment over LiveJournal. It's enraging that nothing was ever done about it despite the countless incidents. You know if the prolific guy out in the open about it faces no consequences then probably nobody else is either.
13
u/study-in-alteRITy Alum Mar 24 '21
I don't get it. I knew kids who got in serious trouble, and some who got expelled, over some pretty minor alcohol offenses. But when it came to really problematic crimes, with existing legal documentation, RIT's attitude seemed to be "but it wouldn't be fair to the poor offender if we had consequences".
2
3
13
u/notespellingof Alumni Mar 24 '21
Can confirm this was a problem. I'm pretty tall and broad, so I can pass for a dude and escaped a certain amount of harassment because of it, but more of my friends had trouble with this than is anywhere near okay. I was asked to (and did) chase off a few of their persistent stalkers, but I always wished there was more I could do.
As a current alum, if there's anything I can do for the students still at school, let me know?
5
u/study-in-alteRITy Alum Mar 24 '21
You sound like an awesome friend. I wish I'd known you in college!
3
u/notespellingof Alumni Mar 24 '21
I mean, no reason not to make friends now I guess? XD
With all the quarantine and everything being online for the COVIDtimes, it's never been more convenient to have online buds.
12
u/pleatgee Mar 24 '21
LOL I go to RPI and know 3 different women with basically the same story:
was polite to a guy for ten minutes at a social function
he figures out her class and walking schedule
ambushes her while she’s eating/walking several times over several weeks
follows her around on campus like it’s his job or something
continues to follow and contact her after she repeatedly telling him politely she’s not interested
posts nasty vitriol about women who lead them on just to play with their feelings.
Personally, I’ve never been stalked, but I have had many creepy things happen to me:
guy changes lab to be in my lab after I blocked him for sending me an unprompted shirtless pic. We were literally talking about multi
guy asks if two different guys are my boyfriend because he has seen me walk with them around campus (none of them were at the time)
many ask if I’m single within literal moments of meeting me....settle down hot dog! I know you’re riled but I just want to make some friend jeez...
I get that young boys are excited and awkward and unaware, and that shouldn’t be held against them, but if you make yourself clear, and they continue to make you uncomfortable, that’s harassment. If a girl says “no” or “I have a boyfriend” or even “...I don’t think so, not tonight...” just back off. It’s basic respect for others’ wishes.
8
u/study-in-alteRITy Alum Mar 24 '21
Oof, yikes. I'm not surprised to hear RPI has very similar issues; as far as I can tell, all the tech schools do.
posts nasty vitriol about women who lead them on just to play with their feelings.
Ugh yeah. This was awful. Especially because it turns out that crazy people consider any human behavior to be "leading them on". I always felt like I had to be so careful to not do anything that I knew a guy wouldn't do, and even then, it never prevented this accusation, it just helped me feel like I could justify my own behavior.
many ask if I’m single within literal moments of meeting me...
Yeah, this really wore me down. On a couple occasions there was a guy just going around the dining hall pointing at women and saying "single?" or "boyfriend?" and walking away if they said no/yes, respectively. After a lot of that kind of thing over and over it made me feel that no one was interested in me as a person or fellow student, only as a potential date (to put it politely).
but if you make yourself clear, and they continue to make you uncomfortable, that’s harassment.
Yeah. I always struggled with this. I didn't want to be rude or mean to the poor awkward guy (and if I had, my classmates would've eviscerated me), but is stuff like "ok, I need to study now", "I'm busy", "I don't want to talk to you", "I'm not interested", "you're making me uncomfortable, please leave" really too subtle a hint?
19
u/dream-in-heliotrope Mar 23 '21
Really glad to see you introducing this difficult and upsetting conversation. The culture shift needs to happen. Any ideas what sort of solutions are out there? Any idea how other schools are more effectively addressing this issue?
17
u/study-in-alteRITy Alum Mar 24 '21
I think the first step is to talk about it (hence, obviously, the posting :P). I'd like to address a lot of the issues that made RIT a difficult place to be as a woman. I suspect fixing them would be a "rising tide lifts all boats" type thing-- a more accepting, safer, less toxic culture would be better for everyone.
If RIT wants to make a concerted change at the administration level, I'd suggest they do research into how other companies, organizations, and universities have effectively addressed cultural problems. There may be some solutions in how fraternities combated hazing in the mid oughts, for example, that could be useful in tearing down RIT's stalking culture.
As a broad plan, I think they need to:
Determine what the problems are
Measure the problems
Try evidence-based solutions
Measure their impact
Any idea how other schools are more effectively addressing this issue?
I've been trying to ask around to see what other women in engineering went through in college for a while (it's a rather delicate subject, as you can imagine-- "oh, you went to WPI? What was the stalking like there?"). Other tech schools also have very similar issues to RIT, including all the stalking (the only thing that appears to be unique to RIT so far is hair sniffing, which I'll make a separate post about, and the other issues seem to be universal... however, I have a tiny sample size due to the difficulty of finding women STEM grads from tech schools). Women in STEM programs at state and typical big liberal arts schools seem to have experienced fewer severe issues of stalking and harassment, although still quite a lot. The one school that's stood out to me is Tufts. I've met two women from there who both talked about being stalked as though it only happened to them once their whole academic career. Obviously this is not a formal study by any means, but I'd like to know what Tufts is doing. (Although in an ideal world, to be clear, the goal would not be Tufts' single stalking incidents per woman, but none.)
I have not come across anything showing that any schools are actively trying to reduce stalking or to make their STEM culture more hospitable. I think there's a lack of anyone talking about it at all-- I found it hard to find stories like mine, which is part of what I want to address with this series.
Research exists showing that there are issues, but there's a dearth of examples showing what things like "harassment" mean (and explaining why they matter). Research even exists showing that a substantial portion of women leave STEM careers in college due to the hostile culture. I suspect if we took some of the money being thrown to get women into STEM and made a concerted effort to improve the culture, we'd have better results than the paltry increase we've been seeing each decade.
24
u/cabandon Mar 23 '21
I’m currently in a situation where I think I’m being stalked but I can’t confirm it yet. However if this dude is actually stalking me, he’s gonna be in for a surprise. You lay a finger on me, i can legally make sure you never have children. I hate creeps.
13
7
u/oldfatguy62 Mar 24 '21
Sorry you had this. My wife did NOT go to RIT, but was a Applied Math major, and picked up a stalker. She had people register for her, he shows up as a transfer into her classes etc. I ended up taking time to meet and escort her around campus. Her father (a Prof and the campus) arranged for people to cover when I was not there (I was already working). (this was before my wife and I were married, but we were engaged)
Anyway, she got out of there. 35 years later, her stalker found her of FB and tried to friend her! Luckily he now lives overseas
6
u/study-in-alteRITy Alum Mar 24 '21
It makes me feel sick to think of her stalker finding her again virtually decades later. That's the kind of thing that keeps me up at night. I'm glad he's across an ocean from you both.
10
u/andyracic1 Mar 24 '21
That's awful that happened to you. I appreciate you sharing the story. Everyone should be able to feel safe all the time. Women have a tough enough time of that as is. Colleges should really endeavor to be extra safe spaces for all their students.
I believe most people are decent and will help a stranger who appears to be in serious distress. I'd love to see training for people to shout / call for help (or whatever the actual best practice is) when need be. And that being normalized. Pretty sure the last time I got any of that was people teaching me about stranger danger in K-6.
Not sure what RIT is doing these for freshman orientation, but I still remember attending a very brief presentation/lecture during orientation where someone basically (nearly literally) told us "guys, don't rape/sexually assault anyone." The fuck? I get that that may have been in response to some problems RIT was trying to address, but are you kidding me with that messaging/programming? You're offending the vast majority of people who would never be sexual offenders, and almost certainly not getting through to the people who need to hear it.
7
u/study-in-alteRITy Alum Mar 24 '21
I was terrified of screaming after this incident. I also, generally, got a lot of flak for complaining about creeps and stalkers-- I do agree that most people are decent and will run to help, but I think a lot of my peers disagreed with me about what a dangerous situation even was. Stalking was not generally considered a bad thing (or at least that was the message I got from responses like "you should be flattered").
I don't recall any anti-rape training during orientation. What do you think would be a good way to approach making a cultural change like this, and how do you reach the problem people without making the reasonable people feel bad?
1
u/andyracic1 Mar 24 '21
I also, generally, got a lot of flak for complaining about creeps and stalkers-- I do agree that most people are decent and will run to help, but I think a lot of my peers disagreed with me about what a dangerous situation even was. Stalking was not generally considered a bad thing (or at least that was the message I got from responses like "you should be flattered").
Eugh! Sorry to hear that too. No idea what drives that kind of reaction/behavior in people. I guess people would rather deny the idea that this kind of thing happens than at the very least accept it, let alone address it. It's uncomfortable to accept that bad things happen to good people.
I don't recall any anti-rape training during orientation.
This would have been back in Fall 2004. It's also possible it was just for guys. It's also possible that it was so insulting, ineffective, and laughably bad it was a short-lived program.
What do you think would be a good way to approach making a cultural change like this, and how do you reach the problem people without making the reasonable people feel bad?
I'm not trained or experienced at all in addressing this sort of complicated systemic problem.
My layman thoughts are to explore:
A) Teaching people (maybe in K-12, maybe as a freshman level requirement) basic human communications. I think there are probably a lot of incredibly lonely guys who simply don't understand how people should communicate with other humans and because they don't have any knowledge/skills to express themselves, they eventually do stupid/horrible things as a result of dwelling on something they want but don't know how to ask for properly. Their poor skills is not at all an excuse for their unacceptable behavior, but I think that solves some of the root causes.
B) Thinking much bigger, our (American, at least) society needs some major cultural updates re: our views on sex/sexuality/partners/women, etc. Unfortunately this is work that takes years/decades/generations, and if not kept up, can easily slide backwards.
I'm kinda rambling a bit now, but, you asked.
5
u/study-in-alteRITy Alum Mar 24 '21
I absolutely identify with the need for A), teach basic human communication. I felt like a lot of issues-- not just stalkers, but a lot of other creepy and weird behavior, stemmed from that.
I'm having trouble picturing how that wouldn't be offensive to reasonable people. It might just be how I'm imagining running that class though. "Ok, kids, repeat after me: women are people. Good. Now, pop quiz: do you treat women like a) regular people, or b) a completely alien species?" Yeah, I definitely think I'd offend all the reasonable guys. Put someone else in charge of creating that curriculum ;)
I do think some schools are making progress these days on B). Although it's tough with college, because kids come in from all over. My freshman roommate didn't know what a clitoris was. As a girl. Didn't recognize the word, was unfamiliar with that body part on herself. K-12 Catholic school.
2
u/mvmlego1212 Alum '19 Mar 25 '21
I still remember attending a very brief presentation/lecture during orientation where someone basically (nearly literally) told us "guys, don't rape/sexually assault anyone."... This would have been back in Fall 2004.
Unfortunately, this was still the approach that they took during orientation a few years ago. (I witnessed the ROO fiasco firsthand.) As you said, it's insulting to the vast majority of us, insufficient against the few who are grossly ignorant enough to harass or stalk people, and completely ineffective against the few who are truly malicious and would commit sexual assault.
1
u/commanderbales Mar 24 '21
They do an anti-harassment assembly during orientation now. Everyone attends. The most notable was Fall 2017? where they introduced ROO (literally rub-one-out) as a way to prevent assault. I came here in fall 2019
4
Mar 25 '21
I get shamelssly stared at pretty much every day. And it's not at my face most of the time. I feel unsafe even in the middle of the day when others are around because I feel like some boys don't know where the boundaries are and just won't leave me along.
4
u/study-in-alteRITy Alum Mar 25 '21
I know exactly what you're talking about. I often felt like I might as well be alone, even in a room full of people, except actually being alone in a room would feel better and safer. The severity of boundary issues guys had ranged from minor to severe, but they all built up until it was overwhelming and I didn't know what it was like to feel safe.
I often wished I had a boy mask I could just put on when I left my house so that people would leave me alone.
4
u/jayliens Mar 24 '21
The fact that this kind of behavior has been normalized is completely disgusting. You deserve to feel safe and comfortable on campus, and I'm really sorry you have to deal with weirdos like that.
5
u/mvmlego1212 Alum '19 Mar 24 '21
Given the reaction of her lab partner, the fraternity guys, and every commenter on this post, I disagree that this behavior has been normalized. It sounds to me like a case of an individual with a really, really messed up understanding of social norms.
I don't say this with the intent of dismissing the harm that his actions caused to the OP, and I certainly believe that she deserves to feel safe on campus. My point is simply that we should be careful to correctly assess the problem.
9
u/study-in-alteRITy Alum Mar 24 '21
Given the reaction of her lab partner, the fraternity guys, and every commenter on this post, I disagree that this behavior has been normalized.
Oh don't worry. I have a lot more stories that make the case that it was.
and every commenter on this post,
Did you notice how many of them also have stalking stories? This is way beyond one individual with boundary issues. This is a cultural issue at tech schools.
5
u/mvmlego1212 Alum '19 Mar 24 '21
I know that stalking on RIT isn't a problem of only one individual, but it's incorrect to claim that RIT, or even GCIS or COS specifically, has a culture of stalking, since the vast majority of students in those programs understand that stalking is bad, and they would act the same way as your lab partner or the fraternity guys if they were put in the same situation.
Perhaps there's a subculture at RIT that encourages stalking (likely fostered through a specific club or two), but placing the blame on the STEM programs as a whole is incorrect and unhelpful.
5
u/study-in-alteRITy Alum Mar 24 '21
but it's incorrect to claim that RIT, or even GCIS or COS specifically, has a culture of stalking,
Source? You make several claims after this, and I'd like to see those sourced too.
The culture I experienced was one of stalking and stalking acceptance. It went across multiple majors in the STEM field. Again, I will be posting for a while, so I think the stories will build up to make this case. Your assertions directly conflict with my experience.
is incorrect and unhelpful.
Unless it is truly a problem in which case, I'm not sure how to address it except to talk about it. I suspect silence is why people like yourself continue to have the impression that stalking is not a serious cultural issue.
3
u/mvmlego1212 Alum '19 Mar 24 '21 edited Mar 24 '21
I the root of our disagreement might come down to differing ideas of what "stalking culture" means. It's a category error to try to prove the existence of stalking culture by listing examples of stalking, because "culture of [X]" doesn't merely mean "[X] occurs frequently"; it also implies that [X] is encouraged through organizational policies and through casual social interactions.
The university itself has no policies that encourage stalking (which is not the same thing as not discouraging it as strongly as it should), none of the paid speakers promote stalking, and the vast majority of administrators, professors, students, and clubs (both in terms of their rules and individual members' attitudes) disapprove of stalking as well. Consequently, RIT does not have a culture of stalking.
As I said before, I'm open to the possibility that there are specific social circles within RIT that encourage stalking, such as particular clubs, sports teams, or residential suites, but the proper way to characterize that would be something like "clubs [C1], [C2], and [C3] have a stalking culture", because it's much more precise about the scope of the problem.
As for sourcing my claims: what you're alleging is widespread criminal activity and accessory to criminal activity. The burden is not on me to prove my former classmates' (or the current math and CS students') innocence, but for you to prove their guilt, and to do so on an individual basis.
Regardless, my sources are exactly the same type as yours: personal anecdotes. Of the plethora of social circles that I've participated in at RIT, none of them served as a forum for discussing stalking in a positive manner, and some of them actively discouraged stalking or similar behavior:
Brick City Boppers gives lessons on dance etiquette, aimed predominantly at preventing female students from being put in awkward or dangerous situations. FemCo has been outspoken in certain sexual harassment cases over the last few years.
On top of that, I've never been privy to a single conversation in which stalking was discussed positively in any of the following clubs, despite my active participation in each for at least a semester: the philosophy club, the Red Barn, the vegan club, PiRIT, one of the three largest religious clubs, or any of the three main political clubs.
(EDIT: refined the list in the last paragraph, and fixed some grammatical errors.)
6
u/study-in-alteRITy Alum Mar 24 '21
I would like to expand my claim to include a general culture of hostility toward women. I submit that certain academic programs have a high tolerance for stalking and other harassment between students. I will also claim that programs with a severe under-representation of women are prone to especially abhorrent behavior.
These are all claims that I can back up with research as well as personal anecdotes. I would invite you to continue reading my posts, and ask you to evaluate both the research and collection of stories, both my own and those from the comments, in a few months, and tell me then whether you think a cultural issue exists.
4
u/mvmlego1212 Alum '19 Mar 25 '21
I would like to expand my claim to include a general culture of hostility toward women.
If you're planning on incorporating that into your next few weeks' Reddit posts about stalking, then I think that's a mistake from a rhetorical/communications perspective.
Simultaneously leveling 1) a specific, quite serious charge (stalking) against a specific target (certain academic programs), and 2) an ambiguous, lesser charge (hostility) against a different target (the university as a whole) is mixing your messages.
I think it's going to result in a lot of conflation, and I think the most ardent skeptics of your claims will pick the weaker of the cases to focus on, putting you at a disadvantage.
I'll follow your posts, but I advise you to adjust your approach, and I once again emphasize that culture involves collaboration between individuals, rather than a bunch of people taking the same sort of actions independently.
3
u/study-in-alteRITy Alum Mar 25 '21
Just to clarify the length I'm talking about: I have twenty weeks' worth of content written, with plans for nearly the same in addition.
I considered front-loading the stalking stories. However, I think it might be more effective to have them spread out. To keep re-introducing the topic. To emphasize how frequent it was, how long it lasted. To add context in between; to explain the typical reaction from peers and friends when I complained about it, to explain how the reactions I had began to build. To tell the stories of the times I spoke to people in authority at RIT about all the stalking.
My overall point is not solely to talk about stalking issues. There were a lot of other issues with sexism, harassment, and violation of consent. Those deserve to be talked about too. Including the "minor" ones. Frankly, I think the people who will ignore frequent stalking stories to try to pick apart a more minor issue of sexism or something.... those people are not the reasonable ones. They're not my target audience here.
2
u/mvmlego1212 Alum '19 Mar 25 '21
My overall point is not solely to talk about stalking issues. There were a lot of other issues with sexism, harassment, and violation of consent. Those deserve to be talked about too.
Yes, but they're distinct things, and it's plausible that your perspective and suggestions regarding one of those issues is considerably more compelling than for another.
Including the "minor" ones.
I agree. My suggestion is that the best way to talk about the issues is sequentially rather than concurrently--not not at all.
I think the people who will ignore frequent stalking stories to try to pick apart a more minor issue of sexism or something.... those people are not the reasonable ones. They're not my target audience here.
This phenomenon is almost ubiquitous in contentious discussions on any topic, and it doesn't require bad faith on the part of either participant in order to occur. It makes sense for people to try to clear up points of disagreement before moving on, which requires focusing on the weakest points in the opposing argument, rather than the strongest.
In fact, you did it yourself in your most recent response by neglecting my point about conflation, which I stand by: if you're freely switching between three or four topics, then discussion will be fragmented, and each commenter will have to take extra caution to clarify which subject they're discussing in order to make their point clear. Undoubtedly, many will fail to do this, and it will lead to unnecessary miscommunication and frustration.
→ More replies (0)1
u/my_name_still_jeff Mar 24 '21
Source?
Nope. If you're going to say that there's some link between studying technology and being a criminal, the burden of proof is on you. What you're purporting at this point is a stereotype. You've mentioned a culture, but not explained any more detail.
I suspect silence is why people like yourself continue to have the impression that stalking is not a serious cultural issue.
You don't need to think that there's some magical link between being interested in technology and being a stalker to think that stalking is a problem. There's no reason to throw people under the bus as stalkers or enablers just for the college they're in. If you can point to evidence of these colleges really providing a culture then you can say there is one, but it's just conjecture without any more evidence. It's not fair to all those people that are totally normal when you try to get those around them to believe that they're enabling criminal activity.
4
5
Mar 24 '21
Source? You make several claims after this, and I'd like to see those sourced too.
The burden of proof is on you here.
2
Mar 25 '21
I mean I kind of agree that it's more of a toxic masculinity/rape culture than specific to RIT, but I do think there's a specific "nerd" rape culture for lack of a better term that normalizes or even romanticizes stalking that is extremely common at places like RIT.
1
58
u/DjStalk Mar 23 '21 edited Mar 23 '21
If you ever have a Stalker... Message me. I'll Stalk them.
EDIT: It wasn't a joke.
29
0
12
u/Double0Lego BS Physics '24 Mar 24 '21 edited Mar 24 '21
For what it’s worth, I always try to position myself so that I’m not in a blind spot when I’m walking faster than someone. I know I’m not going to do anything to hurt anyone, but they don’t, so I try to give space and make sure that if they feel like they need to keep tabs on where I am, they can.
I wish it wasn’t an issue in the world at all, because I know how nice a nighttime walk along the quarter mile can be, and not everyone can feel as safe as I can walking along it.
2
20
u/maureenmcl Mar 23 '21
Hate to hear that this was a problem over ten years ago and is still a problem today. RIT does not care about their students’ safety and it’s been proven again and again in different aspects of campus life.
10
u/Individual-Rock1653 Mar 24 '21
I'm an RIT staff member (woman) and I had a stalker who was another RIT staff member (also a woman) both on and off campus. It was very creepy- I avoided them, blocked them from social media, changed my name(s) on social media, and never reported it. I had just started at RIT and I did not want to be known for being a victim or not be taken seriously or any of the drama and BS that comes along with reporting this kind of crime.
Also- stalking is a problem everywhere, not just tech schools, not just RIT or a subset or programs. There is an interesting, but very dark podcast that covers stalking cases, including college campus cases and cases where students have stalked professors (one case across multiple states, that one is fresh on my mind as that was the last episode I listened to and guess what, law enforcement could not/would not help her) -https://www.instagram.com/strictlystalkingpod/?hl=en.
17
u/DatChumBoi Mar 24 '21
As a dude this just makes me irrationally mad. How hard is it to just not be a douche to women? I do it every day (at least I think I do), these guys should be able to do it too.
8
u/fletch3555 CS '14 Mar 24 '21
I'd argue that there's absolutely nothing irrational about anger in response to these stories
12
u/darklordcalicorn Mar 23 '21
I've never been STALKED but I did have a dude ask for my number and asked me on a date while I was at work. Like, dude, I'm a cashier. I am required to be nice to you. Wtf???
3
u/migmig221 Mar 24 '21
First and foremost, I'm sorry that you had a stalker and that anyone on campus, past or present, has been stalked. That's disgusting and RIT should really do more about this issue. More people need to know this is an issue.
0
Mar 23 '21
[deleted]
12
u/study-in-alteRITy Alum Mar 24 '21
I'm really sorry that happened to you. It's nice to hear from a guy who's been stalked (well... not that it's good, but that I'm glad you're here and talking about it).
I've always wondered if stalkers were usually serial stalkers. It seems like they would be.
I'm glad you got support from your friends, although, yikes. I'm sorry to hear many of them had experience being stalked too.
0
Mar 24 '21
[deleted]
16
u/study-in-alteRITy Alum Mar 24 '21 edited Mar 24 '21
what can we do to make RIT take notice?
Ooof, this is the big question, isn't it? I don't have a clear answer for that. My plan is to post regularly (I'm thinking Tuesdays and Thursdays) to keep the conversation going and get a written collection of issues somewhere publicly accessible. I don't know how to make the leap from that to higher-ups at RIT caring, though.
I do think that this thread shows that a lot of the student body does care. That's amazing and very encouraging.
0
Mar 24 '21
[deleted]
9
u/study-in-alteRITy Alum Mar 24 '21
I considered writing a blog instead of using reddit, and I also considered other platforms. I chose reddit because of the traffic, long-form post style, existing audience, and mod team, which allows everyone to participate in a conversation without things being awful (thanks, /r/rit mods!).
I'd certainly be open to posting elsewhere too, I'm just not sure how much it'd help.
3
u/slice_of_timbo Mechanical Engineering Mar 24 '21
I believe there might be resources for students to set up websites through RIT. I don't know much about it, but it might be worth looking into - and I'm sure there would be more than a few people on here alone who'd be willing to help out
0
Mar 24 '21
[deleted]
4
u/study-in-alteRITy Alum Mar 24 '21
That's a good point. I'm hoping that the [#CampusLife] hashtag would make it easy to do a quick search to get all the stories in one place. We could also ask the mods here for a real flair for campus culture issues (I'd be thrilled if other people could contribute their experiences as posts too).
I think the problem with those options is just basic UX-- it'd be easier for someone to go to a single site than it would be for them to know how to search reddit by keyword or flair. I'm just not sure how big of a deal that is.
0
Mar 24 '21
[deleted]
9
u/study-in-alteRITy Alum Mar 24 '21
I'm not very surprised. I don't think stalking culture could flourish at RIT like this without the help of so many stalker-sympathizers.
0
Mar 23 '21
[deleted]
34
u/study-in-alteRITy Alum Mar 23 '21
I've thought about this a lot, and will cover it more in depth in future posts. But the short summary is:
When I did talk to people in authority at RIT about all the stalking, the experience was worse than keeping silent
Stalking was so routine that I would not reasonably have had time to fill out a report on every incident
3
u/tytye99 Mar 24 '21
I had the same experience where someone I thought was a friend harassed me and trapped me into a very uncomfortable situation. I have not come forward because of how reporting works.
2
u/study-in-alteRITy Alum Mar 24 '21
I'm really sorry. I've had friends do that too. It's a horrible betrayal; not just whatever happened, but the way it crushes your ability to trust friends.
1
u/dream-in-heliotrope Mar 23 '21
Curious as to what your reporting experience was, if you feel comfortable sharing it. Any ideas that could be implemented fairly swiftly to render a more supportive & effective response?
0
Mar 23 '21
[deleted]
34
u/study-in-alteRITy Alum Mar 23 '21
I'd like you to take a second to think through the logistics in reporting an incident like the one in my story.
I didn't know this guy's name. That seems like an issue for a report that would have any effect.
Calling for help at the time would have been an escalation. I also wanted to get away from that guy as soon as possible. Taking down his contact details would have felt like I was extending him an invitation, and I also wanted to avoid that. Frankly, I just wanted to get back to my dorm.
Realistically the most I could have done is call up after the fact and give a description of "a tall skinny guy with glasses", which describes.... a significant portion of the school. That report would not have helped me feel safe from that guy. It would not have helped keep me safe from the next guy. In fact, I'm having trouble picturing how it could have helped me at all, and it would have risked another negative interaction with authority, which always feels worse than not reporting.
And then factor in the time it takes to make a report. I cannot overstate how mundane of an occurrence it was to be stalked. Sometimes it happened multiple times in a week. If you were mid-finals, how much time would you want to spend on the phone with Monroe County Sheriff's office?
I don't think this is a good solution for these issues. I think RIT needs a monumental cultural change where stalking is not the norm in the first place.
7
8
u/disabili-rit Mar 23 '21
you say that like that does something.
you also have to realize its mostly a he said, she said situation and trials can be traumatic. there is also the fear of retaliation
0
Mar 23 '21
[deleted]
10
u/disabili-rit Mar 23 '21
I am a victim of these things, I am giving you MY experiences and what I know from my friends. 97% of women have dealt with sexual harassment of some form, including stalking, and as someone whos been stalked by separate ppl before, i feel entitled to have my opinion
2
u/Individual-Rock1653 Mar 24 '21
Pressing charges makes a traumatic experience very public. You may not be aware of this but when women press charges they are often faced with more harassment, death threats, and - the best part- they are often not believed, or, even more fun, they are blamed for the incident!
For many (not all!) of us it's easier to look after ourselves, warn others, avoid the harasser/abuser, and stay quiet- I can confirm this has been my experience after sexual harassment and sexual assault incidents.
102
u/spooks112 CHST '24 Mar 23 '21 edited Mar 23 '21
My roommate was stalked within the first month or so of being on campus. It lasted for a 3 or 4 days (I was back at home during the bulk of it, unfortunately). This guy pressured her for her phone number after seeing her in line at gracies (she knew this is where she made her own mistake, but she's a very shy and non-confrontational person. Also, who tf tries to pick people up at gracies??). He spammed her phone after that and when she finally answered, he said that it's "about time she answers" and "how dare she not answer". Dude, you only met her a few hours ago? She blocked him after that but I guess he found out which dorm we're in because a couple days later he was casually outside our dorm when she went to go get food (either a crazy coincidence or he was waiting), followed her to get food, followed her back to our dorm, followed her inside (she tried to shut the locked door on the outside on him but this freak stuck his foot in and caught it before it closed). She took another door that would lock him out and luckily she made it in before he did. I got back about 10 minutes after that to her shaking and crying saying how its her fault because she's afraid she wasn't direct enough. Hey Tony, if that's even your real name, you stalked my roommate and made her afraid to leave our dorm because she was afraid you'd be there again. What is wrong with you?